Bob Dylan: Changing of the Guards Meaning
No tags, suggest one.
Song Released: 1978
Changing of the Guards Lyrics
Sixteen banners united over the field
Where the good shepherd grieves
Desperate men, desperate women divided
Spreading their wings 'neath falling leaves.
I stepped forth from the shadows to the...
anonymous Oct 11th, 10:57pm report
Part of it sounds like the revelation received by Bahaullah while imprisoned in the Siyah Chal in Tehran in the 19th century.
anonymous Mar 22nd, 2014 3:10am report
As with all Dylan songs - it means- whatever it means to you at anytime -
Dylan's ambiguity & versatility allows for that -
for his reticence rarely if ever reveals his secret lyrics - avoiding any shattered illusions
Any or all of his lyrics can resonate with our emotional experiences - if we choose to apply them accordingly whatever our belief system -
This is the gift & genius of his persona - that creates amazing imagery in your mind's eye & imagination -
anonymous Sep 24th, 2012 9:05pm report
Dylan once commented: "It means something different every time I sing it. 'Changing of the Guards' is a thousand years old'".
I think this was at a time around which he was becoming actively involved with a christian community as opposed to self study and belief and also i think he was in a relationship with a christian girl.
To me it refernces the plagues of heirachical organizations present through time and in religion. So hes influenced by the thoughts that hes not going to reject Christianity simply because of its hierachical structure, as this is present through human societys history and is a part of that rather than specifically religion. It lyrically is also like its chord progression different for dylan as he comes accross to me in it as an outsider looking in on a situation, one minutes part the next minute out, like maybe his relationship with organised religion.As a piece of music its one of my faves but as a poem its great but useless to analyse beyond the feel of the poem.
however i am a self proclaimed social anarchist and former church goer so this is my personal interpretation.
Anonomous june 10th, you couldn't be further off base with that comment if you were standing. Understanding dylan requires studying his lyrics and the point in time he is performing a classic song. This song is an ongoing story which anon. 11/8 has come pretty close to nailing. I've read about joan of arc and seen a program or 2 about her and after refreshing my mind it could very well be about her, except for the last verse of course.
anonymous Nov 9th, 2011 11:17pm report
The song desscribes the visions of Joan of Arc. The visions described, which were believed to be messages from God, have spiritual and some biblical connotatations.
anonymous Jun 14th, 2011 6:12pm report
Simply put, a kingdom was overrun, and suddenly all the people he thought he knew changed allegiance. The conquering captain took the girl as his own, and when she rejected him, he ordered his men to take her, shave her head, lift her veil, and rape her, probably stone her, and finally kill her. Her best friend and lover goes down to try to save her, but he himself was brutally beaten within an inch of his life. But he survives and, realizing that she indeed was beyond saving, runs away. He goes to the house of an old woman friend and is nursed back to health, but he knows that by now all hope is gone and so he erects a mental and spiritual altar to her memory. And he hopes the men who murdered her will someday be brought to justice.
There's much more to the song that "just" that, but that's enough to form its core.
anonymous Jun 10th, 2011 6:16pm report
Let's look at the whole picture. Dylan has a gift: he is able to poetically and artfully express anything, therefore nothing very well. Small pieces make some sense sometime but everything of Dylan rarely makes any sense. We are mesmerized because we don't have that gift.
changing of the guards is a really weird song. that is until you read the lyrics at the same time the song is being played. you will experience a sort of awakening becaus he doesn't start a line and end it as the last word on the end of the line he realy is starting the stanza in the middle of each verse, he ends the verse at the middle of the next verse or line. it's another side of dylan we have never seen before and it works in a way only he knows why. it's a great song
This is really an apocalyptic song (and I don't mean a song Slayer could ever write!!). He had become a Christian at some point before he made this album (or, maybe, just after this album and before "Slow Train Coming). The lyrics have some caustic references to "Renegade Priests" "Treacherous Young Witches"
"Merchants and Thieves (perhaps interchangeable), hungry for power".
There are scads of Biblical and Ancient Myth allusions. Dylan is certainly speaking from an exalted platform.
"Peace will come/ with tranquility and splendor on the wheels of fire/but will bring no reward when her false idols fall/and cruel death surrenders with its pale ghost retreating/Between the King and the Queen of Swords"
If that's not apocalyptic then what else could it possibly be?
More Bob Dylan song meanings »
Submit Your Interpretation
Related Blog Posts
|Come to Me||anonymous|
|Goodbye My Lover||anonymous|
|Somewhere Only We Know||anonymous|
|We Will Rock You||anonymous|
|Up All Night||anonymous|
|Your Eyes Open||deckerrekcer|
|What Hurts the Most||anonymous|
|Always Be Together||anonymous|