Death Cab For Cutie: Marching Band of Manhattan Meaning
Marching Band of Manhattan Lyrics
If I could open my arms
And span the length of the isle of Manhattan,
I'd bring it to where you are
Making a lake of the East River and Hudson
If I could open my mouth
Wide enough for a marching band to march out
They would make your name...
1TOP RATED#1 top rated interpretation:
I believe this song is about a failed relationship Ben had. He says things about how he wished he could do something for her, like bringing her manhattan in his arms or a marching band in his mouth for her. He's aware that their relationship is falling apart and that he's trying to convince himself it's not. She, on the other hand, keeps struggling with depression. Soon enough, her grief is going to overcome her love for him, and he knows, but he's still struggling to hang on.
anonymous Feb 20th 2017 report
I think it's about a girl who's boyfriend is trying hard to show how much he cares and she won't believe it no matter how hard he tries because she's so weighed down by bad relationships in the past. The sorrow dripping into her heart is self doubt, insecurity,and the baggage from the past. While she's trying to figure out if the glass is half empty (like the past) she's slowing ruining the current relationship that's drowning
anonymous Mar 3rd 2009 report
This is a song about how a man is in love. And yet, the man can't show how he feels so at the beginning he uses these metaphors to try and convey his feelings. Unfortunately, as the song progresses we soon find out that the girl whom he is love with doesn't see any changes in his demeanor and falls into a depression. The narrator then continues to say that if this depression continues then the sorrow will begin to blot out any love she has ever felt for him. This is an unfortunate song just because things like this happens all the time and there is usually no stopping the events once the ball starts on this path. I maybe considered a pessimistic and all but I have experienced this first hand and I was unable to get out of the hole that I was in and now I regret everyday that I have spent afterwards. I continually think about what could have happened but the past is the past and I can't change it.
anonymous Jul 23rd 2008 report
I think you are all being too pessimistic about it. I think its just a love song and he's expressing his love and maybe things are going hard at the moment but as she sits there and wonders if they are going to work he will get better. Her heart will fill back up (drowning her love, but in a good way!)
anonymous Apr 13th 2008 report
I wouldn't exclude the idea of her being depressed, but one way or the other I sort of agree with you. The narrator is a guy who is describing his love for this one girl with these metaphors, but she does feel the same because her sadness is drowning out any chance for love in her heart.
anonymous Dec 26th 2007 report
I agree that this is living for the moment. He knows he hasn't been perfect, he wishes he could do a heap of things to make her see that he's changed, but she can't cant over it... She holds on to what things have been like and can't see what they could be like, and she stays like that, she'll just fall out of love with him... I don't think she's depressed. If someone you loved was depressed, you wouldn't talk about simply screaming there name out for the world to hear. The marching band is a metaphor for his love, it's a romantic gesture--something that he;s failed to do in the past.
More Death Cab For Cutie song meanings »
Blog posts mentioning Death Cab For Cutie
|This is Some Quality Garbage|
|Carolina in My Mind||anonymous|
|Falling Inside the Black||anonymous|
|Ball and Biscuit||anonymous|
|I'm On My Way||anonymous|
|My Name Is Human||anonymous|
|R U Mine?||anonymous|
|Red Cold River||BrokenAndShattered|
|All The Good Girls Go To Hell||anonymous|
|Wish You Were Gay||anonymous|